Friday, January 20, 2017

AN INTELLECTUAL FAILURE OF MASSIVE PROPORTIONS

*                      *                      *
from Chris Knopf   

The political establishment, in which I include government officials, party apparatchiks, consultants, and commentators, is acting like a wounded elephant, after running headlong into a tree—dazed and confused, and lumbering around wondering what the heck just happened.


 In the ad agency business, when the buying behavior of potential customers is directly counter to all the predictions of planning and research, we euphemistically call this a “disconnect”.  Our clients tend to use other words, like “you’re fired.”

What we have in the political world is a disconnect of massive, historic proportions.  I consider it a total, systemic intellectual failure.
             
By intellectuals, I don’t just mean PhD.s or other brainy sorts in various walks of life. I mean anyone who has an active mind, kept enlivened by lifetime learning and intelligent discourse.  If you could find one of these folks who thought a year ago that Trump would be elected president, or Sanders would emerge as a tight second for the Democratic nomination, you’d call them intelligent, but sadly misguided.
            
And yet here we are. 
           
Doubtless thousands if not millions of dollars were spent in recent years on pollsters and opinion researchers that should have revealed what we now know to be demonstrably true:  a huge percentage of voters hate the political establishment, and are in such emotional pain, they’d vote for anyone who said the American system is rigged against them, no matter how it was said. 
            
My experience with market research tells me two things:  all that money was spent asking the wrong questions, or the researchers totally misunderstood the answers they got.  A third possibility is that the people interviewed gave false testimony.  This happens all the time, which brought us New Coke, and why even gifted pollsters like Nate Silver can get it terribly wrong.  Only the deep heart of the respondents knows what they’ll actually do at the moment of decision.  In this case, in the voting booth.
             
I think that’s part of the explanation, but I’m inclined to believe experts heard what people were saying, but didn’t truly understand what they were hearing.  Any researcher will tell you that data means nothing unless properly interpreted. 
            
This misunderstanding worked its way from the information gatherers to the information disseminators—journalists and other commentators—who stirred in their own biases and vested (intellectual)  interests, resulting in a national frame of mind that was diametrically opposed to what was actually going on.
            
Confirmation bias is the scourge of the digital society.  We have so much information flooding our brains, unreliably curated, that we naturally embrace those bits that conform to our view of the world.  This extends to the media we gravitate to, which I’d include regular face-to-face conversations, as our social lives become more and more tribal—economically, ideologically, intellectually. 
            
So it should come as no surprise that the information gatherers, who mostly come from one social class (relatively well off) would unconsciously process the agony of another social class (working people in both parties facing declining circumstances) through their personal filters, however earnestly they believe in their own objectivity.  
           
 I’m reminded of the scene in The Big Short when Steve Carell’s character went to Florida and met a stripper who had something like five sub-prime mortgages.  It was a great Gestalt moment.  Economic catastrophe was about to land on our heads and almost no one anywhere would see it coming. 
           
 I didn’t see it coming either.  Neither did I think for a second that Donald Trump or Bernie Sanders would be realistic candidates (for the record, I hoped Bernie would prevail).  Though I had one moment at the beginning of the campaign listening to an NPR talk show, where a caller from Kentucky wondered about the media fuss over Jeb Bush when everyone he knew was excited about Trump.
          
 I wonder if there was a researcher moderating a focus group of middle-class people in Kentucky, or Michigan, or Connecticut, who heard everyone say that the American system had failed them, that they were frightened and angry, and fired up to do something about it. 

And if the moderator said to herself, uh-oh, these people are going to vote their hearts.  And nobody’s paying attention.

 *                *              *

14 comments:

  1. Cogent analysis. But Trump voters didn't vote their hearts. They voted their anuses.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for this post. Good analysis.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I would highly recommend Le_ meridian funding services to any person in need financial help and they will keep you on top of high directories for any further needs. Once again I commend yourself and your staff for extraordinary service and customer service, as this is a great asset to your company and a pleasant experience to customers such as myself. Wishing you all the best for the future.Le meridian funding service is best way to get an easy loan,here is there email..lfdsloans@lemeridianfds.com Or talk to Mr Benjamin On WhatsApp Via_+1-989-394-3740 Thank You for helping me with loan once again in my sincerely heart I'm forever grateful.

    ReplyDelete
  4. There are cases when it's reasonable to hire a professional than waste time and effort trying to DIY. For the first time in my life I used a Buyessay service and I have no regrets. I spent time on what really felt important to me and successfully turned in the essay on a subject I hated.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Very impressive blog post, I subscribed your blog for your future post. I also have some useful link to share here mcafee activate |

    mcafee.com/activate |

    norton.com/setup |

    norton setup |

    office.com/setup |

    ReplyDelete
  6. Good Work, i like the way you describe this topic, keep going. i would like to share some useful security links here please go through www.mcafee.com/activate |

    www.norton.com/setup |

    www.office.com/setup |

    office setup |

    ReplyDelete
  7. This is really great work , Thank you for sharing such a useful information here in the blog. I have something to share here mcafee download |

    norton download |

    microsoft office download |

    office download |


    ReplyDelete
  8. WPS pin on HP printer represents the "Wi-Fi Protected Setup", it is a 8 digit number that is produced by HP printer for remote association with switches.

    ReplyDelete
  9. British Dissertation Consultants provides quality
    online dissertaion services
    to help students getting over the pressure situation.

    ReplyDelete
  10. British Dissertation Consultants provide best doctoral dissertation writing
    services online in the UK. Our expert PhD dissertation writing service will provide assistance related to doctoral dissertation.

    ReplyDelete

  11. British Dissertation Consultants offer you with the highest quality of Medical Dissertation Services to undergraduates, Master's and Ph.D. students.

    ReplyDelete
  12. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete